Environ Sci Ind J, Volume: 14( 1)
Exposure to Insecticides in Rural Morocco: Study of Serum Enzyme Activity Cholinesterase Biomarkers
- El Haimouti A , Laboratory of Chemistry and Mathematical Modeling, Department of Physics, Faculty Polydisciplinaire, Khouribga, University of Hassan, Morocco, Tel: +212-667 130655; E-mail: [email protected]
Received: March 20, 2018; Accepted: March 26, 2018; Published: May 15, 2018
Citation: A Haimouti EL, S Kettani EL, Azzouzi EL, et al. Exposure to Insecticides in Rural Morocco: Study of Serum Enzyme Activity Cholinesterase Biomarkers. Environ Sci Ind J. 2018;14(1):162
AbstractInsecticides are widely used in developing countries essentially because of the need to increase the agricultural field. Unfortunately, this is done often uncontrolled and without true user protection. Evaluations of the World Organization (WHO), show that every year there are 1 million poisonings involuntary and 2 million poisonings intentional, including 220,000 deaths. These numbers are sufficient to confirm the existence of an important public health problem. Organophosphorus insecticides are absorbed by the skin, lungs and digestive tract. They are widely distributed in tissues and are eliminated slowly by hepatic metabolism. Their Chronic use may result in other peripheral neuropathies affecting the four members and translating by an isolated or associated motor deficit to a sensitive attack. Central impairment is manifested by changes in the behavior of affectivity, memory and vigilance.
Organophosphorus insecticides; Cholinesterase; Cholinesterasemy; Insecticides poisoning
In Morocco, the market for phytosanitary products for agricultural use is between 450 and 600 million DH (40 and 54 million euros), or 0.017% of usage world, for an agricultural area useful range between 8 and 9 million hectares.
In recent years, Morocco imported on average, each year, about 9,000 tons of pesticides (finished products), consumption of these products being strongly linked to climatic conditions [1-10]. In the province Settat, between 300,000 and 500,000 hectares are reserved for cereals. Chemically treated areas vary between 10% and 40%. Most of the time, the treatment takes place with a spray at back, often misused by workers poorly trained who usually do not wear protective clothing .
Our study aims to appreciate intoxication chronic by organophosphorus insecticides through the evaluation of serum enzyme activity (ESA) of the serum cholinesterase (SchE) as biomarker of this intoxication.
Materials and Methods
Area and study population
Settat is located in the center of Morocco. Its climate is arid to semi-arid. Rainfall distribution annual average is around 284 mm with high variability intra- and interannual variation exceeding 30%. The investigation focused on 325 people living in three douars located around the town of Settat. Both DouarDladla and Boukallou are located at the north of the city and douarOuledAfif is located at the southeast of the city.
Each subject participating in the survey has given his free and informed consent after having been informed of the objective of the study, its methodology, it’s constraints, of the agreement of the Ministry of Health and the confidentiality of information provided, as well as his right to withdraw freely to any moment. He answered a questionnaire with anamnestic information regarding the antecedents pathological, drug intake, profession and exposure to organophosphorus insecticides. He benefited from somatic, clinical and complete examination, including neurological.
Determination of cholinesterases
Five milliliters of blood were collected at the level of the brachial vein, by vacutainer, in dry tubes. The AES SchE, was assayed by kinetic spectrophotometer. Cholinesterase catalyzes hydrolysis benzocholine to choline and acid benzoic. Catalytic concentration is determined using the reactions of choline oxidase and peroxidase, from the speed of formation of a quino-amine which is measured at 500 nm. The normal range is between 2150 and 4950 U/L for a temperature reaction temperature of 37°C .
Data entry and processing were made using SPSS software. The v2 test and analysis of variance were used. The difference is significant when p<0.1 .
Results and Discussion
The 325 subjects in the study are aged in average of 29.8 ± 19.6 years and 51.7% of them are female. The 168 female subjects are aged 29.8 ± 18.7 years. The 157 male subjects are aged 29.7 ± 20.6 years.
As shown in TABLE 1, the distribution people surveyed according to sex is quite similar depending on the age, based on insecticide exposure and according to the neurological examination. No women surveyed are pregnant. The prevalence of oral contraceptive use is 41.7% among the women of childbearing age (between 18 and 39 years old).
|Number (%)||Number (%)||Number (%)||P value|
|3 to 13 years||113 (34,8)||55 (32,7)||58 (36,9)||0,65|
|18 to 39 years||107 (32,9)||60 (35,7)||47 (29,9)|
|40 to 64 years||89 (27,4)||46 (27,4)||43 (27,4)|
|65 years and over||16 (4,9)||7 (4,2)||9 (5,7)|
|Direct exposure to insecticides (insecticide handling)|
|Yes||170 (52,3)||82 (48,8)||88 (56,1)||0.19|
|No||155 (47,7)||86 (51,2)||69 (43,9)|
|Normal||l 305 (93,8)||160 (95,2)||145 (92,4)||0.28|
|pathological||20 (6,2)||8 (4,8)||12 (7,6)|
|Users of oral contraceptives|
Table 1: Distribution of study population per sex and age group, and according to exposure to insecticides, neurological examination and use of oral contraceptives among women aged 18 to 39 years with comparaison X2.
The clinical examination did not put a pathological case evidence. So noone has hepatomegaly, neither splenomegaly nor clinical signsof portal hypertension, no edema of lower limbs, no jaundice, no history ofmyocardial infarction, no recent acute infection. Twenty people (6.2%) present a neurological unnatural examination. Peripheral signsare the most frequently noted. This is essentially hyporeflexiadeep tendon. The central signs arerepresented by a hemiparesis withhemiataxia (probably of vascular origin), disorders of memory, apyramidal irritation and tremorattitude. All subjects withcentral signs are men.
The values of cholinesterasemias 325 people subject of the study, are reported in TABLE 2. Cholinesterasemia average of all subjects is 4,059.9 ± 658.3 U/L, that of 157 male people is from 4 114.9 ± 585.7 U/L, while that of 168 females is just that of 4,008.6 ± 717.5 U/L. This difference is not significant (p=0.14). The average values decrease overall with age groups. Children have a significantly higher average to that of adults.
|3 to 17 years||4 215,6 ± 639,7||0.02||4 198,5 ± 751,6||0.11||4 231,9 ± 518,0|
|18 to 39 years||3 967,6 ± 665,5||3 892,7 ± 660,1||4 063,3 ± 667,1||0,27|
|40 to 64 years||3 985,4 ± 670,2||3 930,9 ± 761,5||4 043,8 ± 559,4|
|65 years and over||3 992,2 ± 509,3||4 020,9 ± 316,8||3 969,9 ± 640,2|
|Total||4 059,9 ± 658,3||4 008,6 ± 717,54||114,9 ± 585,7|
|Normal||4 051,3 ± 668,4||0.35||3 994,6 ± 725,2||0.25||4 114,0 ± 595,7||0.94|
|Pathological||4 194,5 ± 475,1||4 290,0 ± 491,3||4 125,8 ± 468,6|
|Total||4 059,9 ± 658,3||4 008,6 ± 717,5||4 114,9 ± 585,7|
|Direct exposure to insecticides (insecticide handling)|
|Yes||4 011,4 ± 630,9||0.16||3 900,6 ± 653,7||0.057||4 114,7 ± 594,7||0.99|
|No||4 113,1 ± 685,2||4 111,6 ± 763,1||4 115,1 ± 579,2|
|Total||4 059,9 ± 658,3||4 008,6 ± 717,5||4 114,9 ± 585,7|
|Users of oral contraceptives aged 18 to 39|
|Yes||3 773,4 ± 753,6 (0,24)|
|No||3 977,9 ± 580,8|
|Total||3 892,7 ± 660,1|
Table 2: Cholinesterasemy (U/L) of study population per sex and age group, and according to neurological examination, exposure to insecticides and use of oral contraceptives.
Mean cholinesterasemia vary a little according to the neurological examination. Direct exposure to insecticides has an effect on AES of cholinesterases at female subjects. Cholinesterasemiais significantly lower among women exposed directly to insecticides.
The distribution of the participants in the study according to the values of the cholinesterasemia is presented in the TABLE 3. No cases of hypocholinesteremia are observed.
|Cholinesterasemy||Total Number (%)||Female Number (%)||Male Number (%)|
|2 150-4 950||317 (97,5)||163 (97,3)||154 (98,1)|
|>4 950||8 (2,5)||5 (3,0)||3 (1,9)|
Table 3: Distribution of study population according to their cholinesterasemy (U/L) and sex.
When monitoring intoxication organophosphorus insecticides, the measurement of cholinesterase inhibition has the greatest interest. We distinguish two types of cholinesterases. Butyrylcholinesterase or serum cholinesterase (SchE), also called pseudocholinesterase, exists in the liver, pancreas, heart, the white matter of the brain and the serum. It is to be differentiated from acetylcholinesterase (AchE), present in the erythrocytes, also called cholinesterase erythrocyte or cholinesterase true [6,14-16]. The rapid and massive lowering of both types of cholinesterases during acute intoxications does not pose problem of interpretation. It is not the same when these biomarkers are used in surveillance of a professional exhibition; indeed, if the AchE has a small inter individual variation (order of 10%), the SchE fluctuates between individuals and physiologically in the same individual. This enzyme being the most accessible to the dosage because of the good conservation of Plasma samples, is often chosen as an indicator of exposure professional.
In addition, a drop in the activity of cholinesterases can also be observed in cases of malnutrition, anemia, inflammation, myocardial infarction, myocardium, pulmonary embolism, dystocia muscle, acute infection or taking certain drugs [15-18].
In our study, no case of hypocholinesteremia has been observed. According to the initial epidemiological hypothesis, a decline was expected in values averages among male sex peopleand especially in older men aged 18 to 39 (most exposed population to insecticides): this has not been observed. On the other hand, people from female sex exposed directly to insecticides have lower values.
This difference probably reflects a differential effect in women. The values in young women (aged under 40 years) are lower and this is especially because she is on oral contraceptives or is pregnant [15,17]. That is indeed verified in our study. The average among women aged between 18 and 39 is the lowest and essentially among those who use oral contraceptives. Susceptibility or vulnerability of women vis-à-vis insecticide poisoning is explainedby several factors: frequency increasing numbers of women in the agricultural work, high illiteracy, few taking precautions, hormonal status and different lipid facilitating the accumulation of certain products [19,20].
Studies carried out among workers specialized in spraying insecticides show more effects or less important on the inhibition of cholinesterases [21-23]. This difference is explained by Ciesielski et al. by the fact that human beings can develop a compensation mechanism and therefore, workers can have normal levels of cholinesterases for the duration of the exposure .
Thus, in the workplace, the evaluation of the core activity should be obtained before any exposure to the minimum on two separate dosages of at least 3 days. Subsequent monitoring will not take into account that a significant decrease : a 40% drop in activity Cholinesterase is a warning sign.
Beyond 50% to 60%, it is necessary to dismiss from its job. The rules are more severe for loaded aircraft pilotsto diffuse organophosphorus [6,17,18]. In case we only have a single exam, as in ourstudy, the clinical diagnosis should notbe based on the conclusions of a unique test but it must integrate the wholeanamnesis, clinical andlaboratory , especially as the importance hypocholinesteremia is not always correlated with the severity ofdisorders related to acute intoxication .
Prevention of insecticides poisoning requires a good education of users. They must wear boots, gloves, a blouse and a mask protector or failing glasses and a hat and comply with the strict spraying rules [11,25,26]. The surveillance of exposed persons done on the dosage of the SchE by not taking account that a lowering of more than 40% compared to basic figures . WHO recommends the subtraction of workers on exposure, in case of inhibition cholinesterases by 30% [3,22].
In our study, although no case of hypocholinesterasemia has been observed, we remain vigilant and we do not formally abandon chronic intoxication with organophosphorus pesticides. Monitoring and the awareness of users about the potential dangers incurred is necessary.
The average value of the AES of the SchE 325 rural people from Settat is 4,059.9 ± 658.3 U/L. It is lower in female sex people and in adults. Nobody presents hypocholinesteremia. This does not eliminate formally intoxication organophosphorus insecticides since more importance should be given to the lowering of the initial rate from 20% to 40%. In all cases, users must benefit from regular training and the rules of hygiene, protection and rationalization of the use of these products.
- Dinham B, Malik S. Pesticides and human rights. International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health. 2003 Jan 1;9(1):40-52.
- Gunnell D, Eddleston M. Suicide by intentional ingestion of pesticides : A continuing tragedy in developing countries. Int J Epidemiol.2003;32(6):902-9.
- World Health Organization. Environmental Health Criteria 63: Organophosphorus Insecticides. Geneva, Switzerland. 1986.
- World Health Organization. Public health impact of pesticides used in agriculture.
- London L, Flisher AJ, Wesseling C, Mergler D, Kromhout H. Suicide and exposure to organophosphate insecticides: cause or effect?. American journal of industrial medicine. 2005 Apr 1;47(4):308-21.
- Baud F, Conso F. Toxicologie Clinique.
- Kintz P. Toxicologie et pharmacologie médicolégales. Elsevier Masson; 1998.
- Harrison TR, Wilson JD, Braunwald E, Isselbacher KJ, Petersdorf RG, Martin JB, Fauci AS, Root RK. Principes de médecine interne. Médecine-sciences. 1992.
- Bouche P, ARNÉ-BESS MC. Neuropathies toxiques. Encycl. Méd. Chir, neurologie. 1997:17-12.
- Cherquaoui S. Secteur des produits pesticides à usage agricole. Rabat : Proceedings du Cinquième Congrès de l?Association Protection des Plantes, 2004.
- Tanji A. Désherbage des céréales. Bull. Liaison Programme Natl Transfert Technol. Agric. 1997;29:1-3.
- Whittaker M, Britten JJ, Dawson PJ. Comparison of a commercially available assay system with two reference methods for the determination of plasma cholinesterase variants. Clini chem. 1983 Oct 1;29(10):1746-51.
- Falissard B. Comprendre et utiliser les statistiques dans les sciences de la vie. Masson; 2001.
- Friedman RB, Young DS, editors. Effects of disease on clinical laboratory tests. American Association for Clinical Chemistry, Incorporated; 1989.
- Kendel M, Bottger R. A kinetic method for determination of the activity of pseudocholinesterase. Klin Wochenscher. 1967;45:325.
- Kachmar JF, Moss DW. Fundamentals of clinical chemistry. WB Saunders, Philadelphia. 1976;652.
- Lawrence AK, Amadeo JP, Steven CK. Clinical chemistry: Theory, analysis and correlation. The Mosby Company, Philadelphia. 1989:42-4.
- Tietz NW. Clinical guide to laboratory tests. WB Saunders Co; 1995 May 4.
- Garcia AM. Pesticide exposure and women's health. American journal of industrial medicine. 2003 Dec 1;44(6):584-94.
- Goldman L, Eskenazi B, Bradman A, Jewell NP. Risk behaviors for pesticide exposure among pregnant women living in farmworker households in Salinas, California. American journal of industrial medicine. 2004 Jun 1;45(6):491-9.
- Self reported symptoms and inhibition of acetylcholinesterase activity among Kenyan agricultural workers
- Smit LA, van-Wendel-de-Joode BN, Heederik D, Peiris-John RJ, van der Hoek W. Neurological symptoms among Sri Lankan farmers occupationally exposed to acetylcholinesterase-inhibiting insecticides. American journal of industrial medicine. 2003 Sep 1;44(3):254-64.
- Ciesielski S, Loomis DP, Mims SR, Auer A. Pesticide exposures, cholinesterase depression, and symptoms among North Carolina migrant farmworkers. American journal of public health. 1994 Mar;84(3):446-51.
- Nouira S, Abroug F, Elatrous S, Boujdaria R, Bouchoucha S. Prognostic value of serum cholinesterase in organophosphate poisoning. Chest. 1994 Dec 1;106(6):1811-4.
- El-Zemaity ME. Evaluation the contamination of sprayer Operators during application of pesticides. Arab J Pl Prot. 2002;20:34-9.
- World Health Organization. Guidelines on the management of public health pesticides. Report of the WHO Interregional Consultation, Chiang Mai. 2003 Feb:25-8.